I'm going to have to listen to the album a few more times before I really can say what I think of it. I like a lot of John Ottman's music, but I've always felt that he was more of a talented amateur than a seasoned professional. But, see, Ottman is the same age as I am and grew up listening to the same scores I did - including Superman - and as a result, I get where he's coming from with his comic book movie scores. The issue here, though, is that Williams material is so striking and recognizable that Ottman's original material doesn't often have the chance to make the same sort of impression. But since much of that may be the very familiarity I have with Williams' score for the original, I will reserve judgement.
I will say that this is light-years better than either of Ken Thorne's Superman scores, though I must admit that I never sat through all of Superman IV, so I can't really make much of a comment on Alexander Courage's work on it.
New alignment evil icon, 'cause I need to be more evil, apparently. Thanks, melancthe.