Joshua Gizelt (swashbuckler332) wrote,
Joshua Gizelt

Kambei the Badass

While I was as surprised as anybody at how different the Henry Brandt conducted 2001 original sessions were from the Jerry Goldsmith recording, I nevertheless found myself defending the Goldsmith recording from its detractors. In reviewing the score for my upcoming Alex North epic compilation, however, I found that it is most likely that my justifications can be chalked up to simple familiarity. While there are clear technical limitations on the Brandt recording (especially in "The Dawn of Man"), the performance and music is very different... and much, much more North-esque. Some of the moments that people were pointing to as being omitted from the Goldsmith recording I don't think were part of the written score, but rather changes made to the music on the recording stage. An extra phrase here, an alteration there, all build up to being a very different track than its analogue on the Goldsmith recording. I have decided that despite the monaural sound, any selections from 2001 I would include on the North epic compilation would, indeed, come from the unused original soundtrack recording.

The North epic compilation at the moment consists of music from Cleopatra, Spartacus, The Shoes of the Fisherman, The Agony and the Ecstasy and 2001. There are other scores that could have been considered - Cheyenne Autumn is something I'd save for a Western compilation someday - but I want to make sure I hit everything I should. I'm wracking my brain for any other epics... which leads to the question of Dragonslayer. Should it be included with the others, which, aside from 2001, are all historical in nature? It is certainly an epic score, but does the film itself count as an epic?

If I was to make a purely musical decision, it would be to include music from Dragonslayer. Many threads from 2001 characterize both that score and Shoes of the Fisherman, and I feel that the scores would fit well together and with the others. 2001, despite its genre, clearly is, but whether Dragonslayer counts as an epic or not is another story.

Any thoughts?



Mingle2 - Free Online Dating

I tried my damndest to fix the code on this thing to get the 40% to display properly, but it resisted my attempts. The smaller banner has a similar problem, so the quiz may just have been invented by somebody who should have been a little more familiar with code before they wrote the meme...?
Tags: akira kurosawa, alex north, cinema, film music, memes, mix workshop, movie moments

  • Audio On the Run

    Okay. I have made a decision that I am going to finish the edit on my [i]Lord of the Rings[/i] mix soon and be done with it. My enthusiasm for the…

  • Onion Dues

    The following is a statement by the Communications Workers of America and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers for release 1 p.m.,…

  • The Return

    It has been a while since I have posted. This has mostly been due to circumstance; I've had quite a few odds and ends floating about. Camera…

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded